期刊名称：JOURNAL OF SHIP RESEARCH
 期刊简介(About the journal)
投稿须知(Instructions to Authors)
About the journal
The Journal of Ship Research is a quarterly publication providing highly technical papers on applied research in hydrodynamics, propulsion, ship motions, structures, and vibrations. While the Journal requires that papers present the results of research that advances ship and ocean science and engineering, most contributions bear directly on other disciplines, such as civil and mechanical engineering, applied mathematics, and numerical analysis. High quality papers are contributed from the U.S., Canada and overseas, with representation from established authorities as well as new researchers.
Instructions to Authors
THE SOCIETY OF NAVAL ARCHITECTS AND MARINE ENGINEERS
JOURNAL OF SHIP RESEARCH
PAPER REVIEW EVALUATION SHEET
A JOURNAL OF SHIP RESEARCH paper should be: Clear, concise, complete, and original, with scientific merit and
logic, with assumptions fully identified, and data and computation results presented with their uncertainty, and with
actual accomplishments of the work plainly stated and fairly appraised.
Reviewer Date
Paper Title
Author(s)
Please complete review within 3 weeks of receipt. If you are unable to do a review, please return the paper
The Paper Profile section below is for the information of the Journal of Ship research Committee only. The
Reviewer¡¯s Comments section on the reverse side of this form will be transmitted to the author(s) if the paper is
thought to be generally acceptable fro publication. Reviewer identity will not be disclosed to the author(s).
PAPER PROFILE
Check the boxes that best describe the following features of the manuscript.
Excellent Satisfactory Unsatisfactory
Originality/Scientific Merit
Contribution to the Marine Field
Completeness of the Reported Work
Clarity of Presentation, Tables & Figures
Reference to the Work of Others
Yes No
Does the technical treatment appear plausible and free of technical errors?
Have you checked the key equations?
Is the notation clearly defined?
Are you aware of prior publication or presentation of this work?
Should the paper¡¯s length be reduced?
FOR PUBLICATION IN JOURNAL OF SHIP RESEARCH
This paper is: (check only one place)
Acceptable
Acceptable with minor revisions*
Acceptable with major revisions* (additional review required after revision)
NOT ACCEPTABLE*
*Please elaborate in written comments on reverse side.
PLEASE COMPLETE BOTH SIDES OF THE REVIEW FORM AND KEEP A COPY FOR YOUR RECORDS
JOURNAL OF SHIP RESEARCH
REVIEWER'S COMMENTS
To assist the author in revising his/her manuscript, please separate your remarks into two sections, as
appropriate: (1) Minor Revisions (Those suggestions which, in your opinion, would improve the quality
of the manuscript but are not essential for publication.); (2) Major Revisions (Changes which in your
judgment should be made before publication)/Reasons for Non-acceptance.
(Continue on additional pages if necessary, or, if more convenient, attach remarks on separate pages.)
(1) Minor Revisions:
(2) Major revisions/Reason for Non-acceptance:
Reviewer's Signature
Date
Reviewer's Telephone
Return Review to:
JOURNAL OF SHIP RESEARCH
Robert F. Beck
2600 Draper Road
Ann Arbor, MI 48109¨C2145
FAX: 734-936-8820
E-mail: rbeck@engin.umich.edu Reviewer's Email Address
PLEASE COMPLETE BOTH SIDES OF THE REVIEW FORM AND KEEP A COPY FOR YOUR RECORDS
Instructions to Authors
jsrreviewform.pdf
|
刊名字顺( Alphabetical List of Journals):
返回页首 